Small, buttery, herb-filled mini stuffings in the form of Stuffing Muffins (aka “Stuffins”) are THE best way to enjoy stuffing this holiday season! Individual servings of stuffing in the form of stuffing cups are cute, delicious, and have lots of crispy-craggy bits, which are the most delicious bites of all.
Plus, Stuffing Muffins are easy to make, with lots of herb flavor from both fresh AND dried herbs, and they’re perfect for making ahead of time. They’re a vegetarian Thanksgiving recipe that everyone will love!
Talk to any stuffing lover, and they’ll argue that there’s nothing better than traditional stuffing. And I was inclined to agree, until these Stuffing Muffins came along, which seriously upped the ante.
I’m a bonafide stuffing lover. Whether it’s a herb-filled vegetarian stuffing, a gourmet chanterelle mushroom stuffing, a simple Crockpot stuffing, or cornbread dressing (yum!), I fully believe that the stuffing is where it’s at for Thanksgiving.
I wanted to create a new stuffing recipe this year, and that’s when I decided to start experimenting with stuffing muffins. Because what’s better than the crunchy, buttery outer bits of stuffing? Nothing! And the stuffing muffin method creates even more of them. I’m sold!
Extra herby, extra delicious. I added both fresh AND dried herbs to this recipe for maximum herbaceous flavor. Poultry seasoning, in particular, is magic for a stuffing recipe!
Super easy to prep ahead of time. You can bake them a few days in advance then warm them on the big day, or prep them a couple of days ahead, cover tightly and place in the fridge, then pull them out and bake them the day-of.
Bread – You’ll need about 8 cups of bread cubes, which is about 1/2 of a large loaf of bread. I like French or Italian bread for this stuffing, but sourdough is always a solid choice, too. Very stale bread is best, or make sure to toast it.
Butter – For greasing the muffin cups, sauteing the veggies, AND brushing over the tops of the muffins. We like them buttery! I like to use unsalted butter for most recipes because I can better control the overall salt content of the recipe.
Onion – Just your standard yellow onion.
Celery – Just enough to add traditional celery flavor to your stuffing muffins.
Garlic – asdf
Poultry seasoning – This cozy mix of sage, marjoram, rosemary, nutmeg, and more is perfect in stuffing. I love it. Find it in the spices and herbs section of most any grocery store.
Fresh sage, parsley, & thyme – I love the look and taste of fresh herbs in my stuffing. That said, I get if they’re hard to find this time of year, and you can totally swap in dried if needed. If you use dried, shoot for about 1/3 of the quantity of fresh – that’s 1 teaspoon for every tablespoon of fresh herbs.
Salt & pepper
Eggs – Eggs help to bind the stuffing together, which is especially important for stuffing muffins as you want them to hold their shape.
Vegetable broth – You can buy it at the store or make your own homemade broth (it’s easy!)
Dairy-free stuffing muffins: Opt for a dairy-free butter.
Prep the bread cubes by toasting them in the oven. If your bread is very stale, you can skip this step.
Preheat the oven and grease the muffin cups with some butter.
Sauté the onion and celery in butter with a bit of the salt. Add the garlic and poultry seasoning (adding the poultry seasoning now helps to bloom the dried herbs for better flavor). Saute for a little bit more, then splash in some vegetable broth to deglaze your pan. Let cool.
Add the bread cubes and the sautéed veggies to a large bowl. Add the fresh herbs along with the pepper and the remaining salt. Whisk the eggs together and pour over the top along with the remaining veggie broth. Stir until well-incorporated.
Divide the mixture between muffin cups, pressing gently to form muffin shapes and doming the tops.
Bake until golden and set.
Brush with remaining butter and serve.
Jump to full, printable recipe
Cut the bread a little smaller than you think you need. I don’t know if it’s just me, but I always think I’m cutting it small enough, then the cubes end up being huge. Go for about 1/2-inch squares.
When adding the broth, keep a close eye on the bottom of the bowl. You want to add just enough veggie broth for the bread to soak up – you don’t want any pooling at the bottom of the bowl. Once it starts pooling, you’re bordering on too much broth (you can throw in a few extra cubes of bread to correct the situation, though).
Mashed Potatoes & Vegetarian Gravy
Vegetarian Meatloaf or Vegetarian Wellington
I hope these whimsical little Stuffing Muffins bring some joy to your holiday table this season! They’re a fun – and tasty – way to enjoy one of the very best Thanksgiving sides.
Use dairy-free butter.
The post Crispy Buttery Stuffing Muffins appeared first on Kitchen Treaty.