What is the rarest whisky in Scotland?

There is a certain aura surrounding the very rarest of the rare… an allure… dare we say, a mystique?

It could be a Rothschild Fabergé egg, some of that ‘white gold’ Caviar we’ve been enjoying, or, the rarest of the rare, a first edition Crystal Charizard. 

It could even be a limited edition, single cask, vintage single malt Scotch whisky from one of Scotland’s most hallowed distilleries. 

Now, we aren’t just talking about scarcity here. Of course, any single cask whisky is rare, given that there are so few bottles to be had. What people really mean when they ask the question “what is the rarest whisky?” is “what’s the most expensive (and rare) whisky?”

To answer this question, let’s first start by looking at the various criteria that make a whisky rare and (what you really want to know)… expensive.

What makes Scotch rare?

Age and ageing

So the first factor is the age of a whisky. Everyone knows older whisky tends to be more expensive. Is it because it’s better? Not necessarily, no. Often it can pick up all kinds of complex flavour and depth from the maturation, but age doesn’t always equal quality.

However, when it comes to older whisky, there is certainly much less out there. Part of the reason for this is it’s more costly to make. You have to use up space in a warehouse, you have to watch over the stuff, and you need to ensure the conditions remain just right. Additionally, why wait 40 years for a whisky to be ready, when you could bottle it after just 10 and make a more immediate profit? 

There’s a final aspect here: the angels’ share. This is the annual evaporation (around 2% per year) of spirit from the cask. 2% per year quickly adds up, leaving you with less and less of that precious nectar.

Limited editions

Often distilleries will do limited runs of a product. Perhaps it’s a special commemorative bottling, or something more experimental. Anyone who’s followed the Ardbeg Fèis Ìle releases will be aware of how quickly they sell out, and how quickly they skyrocket in value on the secondary market.

Limited editions are often highly prized, particularly if they’re an especially good spirit, or have a notable, unique flavour to them.

As we mentioned previously, single casks also make for extremely valuable and, by their very definition, rare collector’s items. Most whiskies, be they single malts or blends, will be the product of many casks combined. This allows distilleries or brands to create consistent products year on year. If you take a single cask, you are limited to however many bottles you can get out of it. In the case of a standard ex-American oak bourbon barrel, that could result in fewer than 200 70cl bottles! 

Lost distilleries

Lost or closed distilleries represent some of the rarest and most exciting whiskies of all. You can own a piece of history, otherwise lost to the ages, knowing it will never be made again. Of course, that all can change if the distillery reopens years later. One example of this is Port Ellen, which was closed seemingly for good in 1983. As of 2022, there were plans in place to reopen its doors once again, and it’s currently being rebuilt. That same year, a rare cask of Port Ellen distilled in 1979 was auctioned at Sotheby’s for a whopping £875,000!

Packaging and presentation

Some of the rarest and most valuable Scotch whiskies also boasted unique, distinctive packaging. Take the 60 Year Old 1926 Macallan with hand-painted artwork by the Irish artist Michael Dillon. In 2018, a bottle of that went for £1.2 million at a Christie’s auction. Many other examples come in beautiful wooden presentation cases or Baccarat crystal decanters.

Prestige factor

One of the benefits of running one of the older, more illustrious distilleries is the prestige factor surrounding the spirit. There’s a reason a list of the most expensive single malts will feature names like Dalmore, Macallan, and Glenfiddich. They’re recognisable names, and they’ve built reputations over centuries. Prestige doesn’t equal quality, but it does often indicate that there’s something good going on. 

The most expensive whisky at auction

Macallan Cask #263, an ex-sherry hogshead, has become something of a celebrity in the whisky world. In fact, several of the most valuable bottles ever to be sold came from this very cask. This includes the most expensive Scotch sold at auction. The cask in question was filled in 1926, and was aged for 60 years before bottling. 

By the time it was bottled, the entire cask yielded just 40 bottles. 12 were sold soon after bottling, then in 1993, another dozen were put on the market. These were given stunning labels created by the Italian pop artist, Valerio Adami. 16 remained, and these were either offered as part of Macallan’s vintage release programme, or in the case of two, auctioned in blank bottles.

In 2023, a beautiful example of the Adami-labelled batch (see picture above) went for auction at Sotheby’s. Its pre-auction estimate was a whopping $1m. However, it hit the million-dollar mark and kept going, eventually fetching a staggering $2.7m. 

It’s said to have a very rich, sherry-driven nose with figs, oak, and hints of smoke, and a palate of dried fruit, spice and thick molasses. It sounds pretty lovely, to be honest with you.

5 of the rarest whiskies on Master of Malt

For the whisky enthusiasts among you, we present, the rarest (read: most expensive) Scotch whiskies available right now for sale on this here website. Do note, this is accurate as of early 2024. Someone may have since purchased one or more of these in some impulse buy at checkout. You know, like getting a delicious KitKat Chunky Black & White bar when you’re queuing for the till at Tesco.

So, in order of cheapest (and we use the term advisably) to most expensive…

#5 Dalmore 43 Year Old 1969 (Cask 1) – Constellation Collection 

This came from a private owner. It’s part of the Dalmore distillery’s stunning Constellation Collection, which is a range of 21 vintages from between 1964 and 1992. They’re all bottled at cask strength and come packaged in stunning decanters and display cases. 

This example was matured for 40 years in a white oak barrel, before a finish in a small-batch bourbon barrel for extra bourbon-y goodness. It’s said to have a nose with notes of apple, pear and caramelised orange, and a cinnamon-led, toffeeish, cherry-like palate with banana bread and sultanas. That does sound pretty good.

#4 Dalmore 45 Year Old 1966 (cask 7) – Constellation Collection

For those of you for whom the entry in the #5 spot wasn’t quite old enough, we have the rarer-still Cask 7. This was distilled in 1966 and it spent a whopping 37 years in an American white oak bourbon cask. It was then moved to a Matusalem Oloroso sherry cask for a further 6 years. Then, going back to resolve some unfinished bourbon business, it was re-casked a final time for two years in a bourbon barrel. 

Dalmore’s tasting notes speak of aromas of blood oranges, apples, pears, melons, cinnamon spice, floral hints and cocoa. They go on to describe the palate as a mix of ripe mandarins, kumquats, Black Forest fruits and pineapple, with ginger, treacle, liquorice and vanilla. 

#3 Bowmore 1969 50 Year Old – Vaults Series

Making it onto the podium, we have a 50 Year Old Bowmore from the Vaults series. It’s a mix of spirits aged in American oak bourbon casks and Spanish oak oloroso sherry casks. It’s bottled at natural cask strength, and comes with a lovely presentation case which was made by John Galvin, a master craftsman who took inspiration from the very Bowmore warehouse in which the whisky aged.

This is said to be a tremendously complex whisky, with a range of flavours from floral notes to lemon meringue, grilled nuts, fudge and a heft dose of spice.

#2 Glenfiddich 50 Year Old Simultaneous Time – Time Reimagined

This Glenfiddich comes in an exquisite decanter made by the glassmaker Glasstorm. The whisky itself was aged for five decades in three casks, watched over by three generations of malt masters. It was then bottled in a decanter with three faces, and these represent the three pillars of whisky (as opposed to the Seven Pillars of Wisdom). These pillars are the water, the air, and malted barley. It’s presented in an aluminium canister created by data artist Manuel Jiménez Garcia. 

Glenfiddich describes a nose of citrus, Madeira cake and muscovado sugar, and a palate with lingering sweetness, oak tannins and sun-dried vanilla.

#1 The Macallan 50 Year Old – The Red Collection 2020 Release

Finally, taking home the gold medal as the most expensive bottle of Scotch on our humble website, we have a 50 Year Old Macallan. It’s aged for half a century in sherry-seasoned European oak, and it’s packaged in sustainably sourced European oak. The distillery describes a nose of antique oak, leather, cocoa and cherry, and a palate with dried fruits, spice, dark chocolate and orange. 

 

The post What is the rarest whisky in Scotland? appeared first on Master of Malt Blog.