Skip to main content

Thanksgiving Pies: Classics, Curveballs, and Savory Slices

Whether you’re a pumpkin pie purist or the one people count on to bring something adventurous, this roundup has a recipe for everyone’s Thanksgiving table. We’ve gathered the classics you look forward to every year, a few creative twists to surprise your guests, and savory options that make the perfect starter or side to the feast.

Fair warning: we’ve taken some liberties with the word “pie.” You’ll find hand pies, tarts, and even quiches here too. Because we believe that anything with a flaky, buttery, or crumbly crust deserves a spot at the Thanksgiving table.

 

Classics

Pecan Pie

For our Gold Standard, we opted to go back to tradition and use butter and brown sugar for a creamier, custard-like filling. Paired with our favorite All-Butter Piecrust and a topping of crunchy halved pecans, this pie is a classic for a reason.

Apple Pie

Crisp, sweet apples and a warming spice blend are wonderfully paired with a flaky, all-butter crust in our Gold Standard Apple Pie. The apples are cooked down on the stove first to ensure they won’t release too much liquid once baked, avoiding the dreaded “soggy bottom” crust.

Lattice-Topped Pumpkin Pie

Topped with a golden, woven crust, our Lattice Pumpkin Pie is the ultimate symbol of those warm and cozy feelings of fall. 

Chocolate Chess Pie

Here, the classic goes dark, with a little espresso powder doing what it does best: making chocolate taste more like itself. Placing the pie directly on a preheated steel helps brown and set the pastry quickly—delivering a crisp, fully baked base instead of a dreaded soggy bottom.

 
 

Butternut Squash Pie

Forget pumpkin and sweet potato. This bourbon-spiked squash pie is the new star of your next holiday dinner. This pie embodies all that a custard pie should be, appearing firm with clean slices, but dissolving into silky deliciousness with every bite.

 
 

Getting Creative

Chai Spice Caramel Pie

This luxurious pie offers a medley of spicy, salty, sharp, and sweet. Our crisp Gingersnap Crumb Crust is the perfect cradle for the light, velvety caramel filling topped with billowy, torched meringue.

Speculaas-Pumpkin Chiffon Pie

This isn’t your grandma’s pumpkin pie. A buttery crumb crust made of speculaas cookies and roasted pistachios and a fluffy yet wonderfully rich pumpkin chiffon filling elevate the original, but it’s the Chinese Five-Spice Mix that really sets this Speculaas-Pumpkin Chiffon Pie apart.

Pecan Pie Pastry Sandwiches

A favorite dessert for fall gatherings, pecan pie gets a much-deserved makeover as a pastry sandwich. The sweet, rich, and gooey filling that everyone knows and loves is sandwiched between flaky and buttery piecrust rounds. They’re then rolled in chopped pecans for the perfect balance of crunchy, flaky, and tender goodness.

Fig Cheesecake Pie

Jammy fig preserves are swirled throughout a creamy cheesecake filling, all set atop a buttery, spiced gingersnap crust for the ultimate in decadent desserts.

Honey-Vanilla Pear Hand Pies

This is a nod to the Southern fried hand pie—the kind traditionally stuffed with dried apples or peaches—but more specifically, it’s an homage to test kitchen director Laura Crandall’s mother, who made them for the holidays. 

Satsuma Cream Tart

Inspired by the nostalgic Orange Creamsicle ice pop, our silky-smooth filling is nestled within a crisp, indulgent chocolaty shell, creating a decadent combination of flavors and textures that captivate with each bite.

Appetizers, Mains, and More

Pear-Walnut Crostata

This crostata’s rustic buttery crust is infused with the earthy richness of ground walnuts, perfectly complementing the filling of salty pancetta, luscious Bosc pears, and creamy blue cheese—a combination that is pure magic.

 
 

Artichoke Tarts

Topped with tender artichoke hearts and a sprinkle of fresh thyme, these Artichoke Tarts are a celebration of taste and texture.

Root Vegetable Tarte Tatin

Balancing upon a knife’s edge of savory and sweet, this gorgeous Root Vegetable Tarte Tatin blends the earthy flavor of root vegetables with a sweet-tart sherry vinegar-spiked caramel. This twist on the classic is as stunning as it is delicious. Plus, it transports and reheats incredibly well, making it the perfect showstopping bake for your next holiday get-together.

Potato Curry Hand Pies

A combination of fresh ginger, garlic, curry powder and paste, cumin, allspice, bay leaf, black pepper, and fresh cilantro give each hand pie a nuanced depth of flavor, and fork-tender vegetables add just the right amount of textured bite. Plus, they’re perfectly portioned to serve at your next get-together.

Mushroom Quiche

Oven-roasted mushrooms and garlic are incorporated into this eggy delight to create an earthy, aromatic quiche. A pinch of ground white pepper adds a little sharpness to the filling while finely chopped pecans add to the rich, buttery taste of the pâte brisée. Altogether, this quiche is pure comfort.

The post Thanksgiving Pies: Classics, Curveballs, and Savory Slices first appeared on Bake from Scratch.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.